It’s the Eve of #CanadaReads!

2016 CBC Canada Reads Shortlist

When I first started this blog, one of the big things that I wanted to accomplish was to foster a love for Canadian Literature, or CanLit. For a long time, I had discounted CanLit because I had a really outdated idea that it was boring. I don’t even know where I got that thought from! Well, I’m so glad that I have discovered otherwise because there are some truly fantastic Canadian books out there. Not only that — there are also so many ways to celebrate CanLit, including Canada Reads which starts tomorrow!

If you’re unfamiliar with Canada Reads, it’s basically a battle of the books type competition featuring 5 panel members who each defend a book that they believe best fits the year’s theme. This year’s theme is “starting over.” The four-day debate can be watched live online, on TV, or on the radio. Click here for more information!

Like most years, I challenged myself to read all 5 contending books and I was so so close to completing it this year. I ended up reading 4 of the 5 books in full, and unfortunately put down the last book after reading a few chapters because I wasn’t quite feeling it. That being said, here’s my breakdown of the five books:

Birdie by Tracey Lindberg (Defended by Bruce Poon Tip)
First line: “Maggie sits in the old tavern, amongst friends.”
My thoughts: Birdie is a complicated one for me, because I understand its significance but I spent half of the book not quite getting what was happening. It wasn’t until I got to see things from the perspective of other characters that I really truly “got” what was happening. While I think that’s more a shortcoming on my part, it did affect how I felt about it. That being said, I’m so excited to hear Bruce Poon Tip defend Birdie, as I think it will help me understand and appreciate the novel more.

Bone and Bread by Saleema Nawaz (Defended by Farah Mohamed)
First line: “If you listen, you can almost hear the sound of my son’s heart breaking.”
My thoughts: I loved Bone and Bread. I’m a sucker for family stories — especially if it has to do with sisters — and Bone and Bread was gut-wrenching and beautifully written. This is a book with characters that you’ll want to root for and care for, and I can’t wait to watch Farah Mohamed defend it in the debates.

The Illegal by Lawrence Hill (Defended by Clara Hughes)
First line: “Go home.”
My thoughts: Surprisingly, this was my first time reading Lawrence Hill. I was blown away by the complexity of the book, given how readable it is. Keita Ali has not had an easy life and he is fascinating to read about (and cheer on), but what ultimately impressed me the most about this book was how much I got sucked into each character’s story arc. Now that’s great characterization.

Minister Without Portfolio by Michael Winter (Defended by Adam Copeland)
First line: “She told him there wasn’t another person.”
My thoughts: This is the book that I didn’t end up finishing, so I’m going to really pay attention to what Adam Copeland says about it during the debates. (I always find that I appreciate a book more when I hear someone fiercely defending it.) I didn’t keep reading the book because I unfortunately didn’t feel like I cared about Henry enough.I’m sure the “point” of the book was to watch Henry grow as a person, but I just wasn’t compelled.

The Hero’s Walk by Anita Rau Badami (Defended by Vinay Virmani)
First line: “It was only five o’clock on a July morning in Toturpuram, and already every trace of night had disappeared.”
My thoughts: This was another book that I loved. And, surprise! It’s a book about a family. I especially loved this book because it features a child who is displaced to a completely foreign country (from Canada to India). As someone who also moved to a foreign place when they were young (I moved from Canada to Hong Kong in grade four), I could relate to seven-year-old Nandana but also appreciate how hard the adjustment must be for the adults as well. Everyone in The Hero’s Walk has their own story, problems, and regrets, and it was a fantastic character-driven novel.

So, who do I think will win? I have no idea! All five books have characters who are trying to find themselves and start over in a way. I’m just excited to see fellow book lovers defending their picks!

Did you read the Canada Reads shortlist? Are you rooting for a particular book? Let me know!

9 thoughts on “It’s the Eve of #CanadaReads!

  1. Naomi says:

    I feel the same way as you this year – I really don’t know how it’s going to go. I like all the books, and they all fit the theme. Can’t wait!

      • Naomi says:

        Yes, I even got to watch it live this morning. It was a snow day for the kids, so I put my son’s headphones on and ignored them for an hour! 🙂
        I get so nervous. Is it just me?

  2. The Paperback Princess says:

    Karen! I read TWO of the books! WHAT?!
    I can’t believe that you hadn’t read Lawrence Hill before now! Get on that! He’s a MASTER.
    So I read A Hero’s Walk and Bone and Bread. I liked A Hero’s Walk but ultimately, something about it didn’t click for me. I really liked Bone and Bread though. Everything you said about it, yes.
    I think that Birdie is what will ultimately win but I think it will come down to that and The Illegal. I’m totally cheering for Bone and Bread though!

    • Karen says:

      Eva! I’m so proud! I definitely need to get on that; The Illegal was so good. It’s rare for me to cry during the first half of a novel but this one definitely did it for me. I would say, if I had to compare, that I prefer Bone and Bread just slightly over A Hero’s Walk. It took me a little bit more to fully feel immersed in A Hero’s Walk, but with Bone and Bread the connection was instantaneous. And the writing! So beautiful.

      • The Paperback Princess says:

        It was really beautifully written. And so relatable – which for a book about orphans in a place where I don’t live, is no small thing.
        The Hero’s Walk was really beautifully written too though. I remember pausing over some sentences marvelling at her prose.

  3. mrsqbookaddict01 says:

    I had many of the same feelings about the Canada Reads books. I wanted to love Birdie because of the topic, but I couldn’t get through the book. I really struggled. I also love The Hero’s Walk!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s